Vermont Public is independent, community-supported media, serving Vermont with trusted, relevant and essential information. We share stories that bring people together, from every corner of our region. New to Vermont Public? Start here.

© 2024 Vermont Public | 365 Troy Ave. Colchester, VT 05446

Public Files:

For assistance accessing our public files, please contact or call 802-655-9451.
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Adrian: The Undiscovered Justice

In a philosophical moment, Star Trek’s Mr. Spock professed that “logic is the beginning of wisdom; not the end.” And such is the case with the law and ethics. For those aspiring to higher levels of ethical conduct, the law sets the floor for behavior, not the ceiling – thus leaving space to navigate in between.

Long time Vermont Supreme Court Justice John Dooley has announced that after 30 years, he will not be seeking reappointment when his term ends in March, 2017. Until then - unlike the vacancy on the United States Supreme Court created by the death of Justice Scalia - Justice Dooley will be fulfilling all duties and the Court will maintain its full compliment of five justices.

In Vermont we’re lucky that our High Court has mostly avoided the political polarization that’s haunted the US Supreme Court. Still, although the Vermont Justices officially have to stand for reappointment by the legislature every six years, practically speaking, their appointments amount to life tenure (albeit with a mandatory retirement age of 90). Thus, one of the ways that a sitting governor can substantially impact his or her legacy is through the appointment of a Justice.

Judicial appointment by the Governor with confirmation by the legislature is a relatively new development. Until the 1970s, through a mix of law and tradition, vacancies were filled by the legislature through direct election of the most senior trial court judge. It wasn’t really until 1981 that someone outside of the judiciary was appointed to the High Court.

The statute on appointment of a new Justice allows the process to begin when a judicial vacancy or contemplated vacancy occurs. However the Vermont Constitution only discusses actual vacancies. Regardless of what a sitting governor can do under the law, the real question in a scenario like this is what a sitting governor should do.

At a recent debate neither Phil Scott, nor Sue Minter sounded pleased with Governor Shumlin’s decision to appoint a Justice, while having one foot out the door of the Governor’s Suite. It’s clear - at least from the outside looking in - that the Governor is trying to shore up his own legacy, rather then take the high road and let his successor make the appointment.

Perhaps the words of Philosopher/Wizard Albus Dumbledore are equally relevant in this instance and the Governor must “face the choice between what is right and what is easy.”

Ed Adrian is an attorney at the law firm Monaghan Safar Ducham PLLC. He previously served on the Burlington City Council for five years and currently sits on the Burlington Library Commission.
Latest Stories